This week I have been struggling with this idea of personal identity - not in the abstract, but in very concrete and specific terms. To put the point on it, I have been struggling with the answer to the question of who I am. Who is Joseph Boggs?
I can locate myself in a physical milieu. I live in Oklahoma City, OK...in the southwest quadrant of the city close to the airport, in a three-bedroom, 1 1/2 bath house. I drive either a Saturn Vue or a Pontiac Grand Prix. All this I can say about myself, but it is not my identity.
I can locate myself in a professional milieu as well. I am "Pastor Joe." I attempt to shepherd the congregation of May Avenue Wesleyan Church from day to day and week to week. I attend district meetings and events. I have two degrees that tell me I can do this, and I am licensed to do it. But like my physical milieu, this is not my identity.
I can even locate myself in a relational milieu. I am married to Melissa and the father of Hannah and Ike. I have a great mom, dad, and a sister that most brothers would kill for. My in-laws love me and I them. My niece is named Kate, and I have an as yet unborn niece or nephew on the way. But again, my identity is not these relationships.
Somewhere along the line of my life, I have lost my sense of identity. As far back as I can remember, I have worked hard to make people happy. Not everyone and not all the time, but I have been a chameleon of sorts, changing my color to fit the situation. When I was young, I wanted my mom to think I was a good son, so I would (occasionally) clean my room or try real hard at school. To be sure, my mother didn't "force" me in any way to be like this...I just was. I wanted my sister to think of me as a cool little brother, so I offered to beat up guys two years older than me and twice my size.
As I got older, this trend didn't change - in school, I wanted people to like me, so I did stupid things and ended up in military school. After military school, I wanted to make my Dad "proud" and I wanted him to see me as something more than the kid who has never quite figured it out. Again, it never seems to matter that my Dad has repeatedly told me how proud he is - I deceive myself into believing it isn't really true - that he, like so many others, is just benignly tolerating me.
In college it was professors - I wanted to be the smartest student, so I asked more questions and wrote longer papers. I even do it now - I try to shape my thoughts, ideas, and feelings into forms that are pleasing and comfortable to the people of my church and, most importantly, to my wife. I even do it with God - assuming that God won't like the "real" me (even though I can no longer even identify who that is).
I don't know why I compulsively do this, but I fear that, in doing so for so long, I have forever lost myself, the one who God created me to be. There is a song by Blue Man Group called Persona, and the second verse has the following lines talking about the masks, the roles that people play:
In the evening I take it off
But there's another one underneath
And I can't seem to find
the bottom of the stack
I might just lose my mind
and never get it back
The song, which is one of my favorites, captures my feeling so well. Am I so afraid of who I might be that I have forever buried the unique me? Am I so concerned about being rejected that I won't let down my guard? Can I continue to live as the guy without an identity, the chameleon? What will happen if I never discover my true self that has been buried for so long under an avalanche of faces and masks - the faces and masks of complete strangers?
These are my questions. May God grant me the answers.